My Character Hijacked My Story. Now What?

Imagine this: a writer prepares an outline for a new novel. The writer takes great care to develop the story. His main character is well-defined. There is a clear story arc. The writer has listed the key events. It’s all there: the premise, the theme, the entire piece. And then the writer sits down to write.

About one-third of the way through the story, the writer makes a shocking discovery. He didn’t see this coming. Something is very wrong here. What happened? One of his characters has hijacked the story. This wasn’t part of the outline. It wasn’t even in his head. Worse still, it’s not the main character who has stolen away with the story.

This scenario happened to me during the writing of my National Novel Writing Month novel. It’s still happening and guess what? I am making no attempt to stop it from happening. How did this happen? Let me share some background. My story centers on an aging, alcoholic lawyer, Frank O’Malley, who is dying of cancer. His last wish is to reconcile with his estranged daughter, Maura. When I wrote the outline, I had the idea that Frank was the main character. Maura would exist as a sort of spectral presence–a mysterious figure who walked out on her family ten years earlier and kept her whereabouts from her loved ones.

As I started to write the first scenes, I labored over every scene with Frank in it. There are only so many ways one can write the interior monologue of a dying man, wracked by regrets and grief over the disappearance of his daughter and the death of his wife. When I wrote the scenes about Maura–this ghostly presence–a strange and wonderful thing occurred. Maura came alive. I traced her journey from the day she discovered she was pregnant, to the argument with her father that resulted in her leaving home, to Maura moving in with her rock musician boyfriend. And then the dramatic moment came to me: her boyfriend abandoned her and she was evicted and forced out onto the streets of Boston during one of the worst snowstorms the city had ever endured. From there, the events and scenes flowed one after another.

When I reflected on the reason Maura emerged as the central character, it was obvious. Her story involved action, movement, adversity, obstacles and daunting struggles she had to overcome to reach her goal. Frank’s story was a downward arc; he was dying and would continue to die and then he would be dead.

How does a writer know when a character has hijacked her story? The scenes involving this character come easy. The writer can’t wait to finish one scene and get to the next one. Conversely, the scenes involving the original main character become a struggle. The writer stares at a blank screen, unable to come up with real scenes and authentic story lines.

Here are some tips for dealing with rogue characters:

  • Roll with it, at least until the story plays out. Even if the new main character completely changes the story arc, see where it leads.
  • Define what it is about the new main character that is so interesting. Does this character have deeper motivations and internal struggles? How can the writer best maximize those challenges?
  • Consider the possibility of more than one main character. When I read Barbara Kingsolver’s classic novel, The Poisonwood Bible, I had a hard time sorting out who the main character was. I had a similar experience with The Time Traveler’s Wife, by Audrey Niffenegger. It was clear Henry DeTamble was the main character, but Clare had an equally important and symbiotic role in the story.
  • Reassess your decision once you have completed the first draft and given yourself time to reflect. Did it work as well as you thought? Or was your original outline the right way to go?

Have you ever had a major character hijack your story? How did you deal with it?


Filed under Uncategorized

8 responses to “My Character Hijacked My Story. Now What?

  1. Absolutely, I have had characters take over. The love interest becomes the hero, instead of being kicked to the curb. The little girl stops being an accesory and takes me on a ride.

    And I let them, despite the time it might take find out if their journey will be more than just a side trip. I find that the story my subconscious is trying to tell is often more exciting or meaningful than the one I’d imagined– and once it has flowed freely, my well-used hindsight helps me to craft the whole into a neatly plotted story.

    • Mary,
      Thanks for your comment. That is a great point you made about the subsconscious and its impact. Sometimes I think these ideas come out of nowhere, but our subsconscious is very powerful. I say, “let it flow” and see where it takes you. Thanks again.

    • Mary,
      Thanks for your comment. That is a great point you made about the subsconscious and its impact. Sometimes I think these ideas come out of nowhere, but our subsconscious is very powerful. I say, “let it flow” and see where it takes you. Thanks again.

  2. If my characters evolve from the early ‘draft’ versions of themselves as the story grows, then I will let them shape the world around them to suit their new personalities. The result is invariably a better story and a more well-rounded character.
    Would you mind if I referenced this page to my own blog page ( that can write their own story)?

  3. Pingback: Can your characters speak to you? | When I Became an Author

  4. I write a Funny, spicy Romance series with a paranormal element– the blind main character, Teresa, is able to communicate with her companion dog, Red. Book 1 revolved around a love triangle, I knew exactly who she would fall in love with. Wrong– in chapter 19, I realized she would end up with the other on. Book 2 I was writing chapter 2 and something happened to change the complete direction of the series, and expanded my intended trilogy into at least 5-6 books (I am currently writing book 6- we shall see if my characters let me end this). Also, in book 2, I was on the last chapter when the characters threw in a monkey wrench (I think I was as surprised as the readers by this cliffhanger ending)… through the series, each character’s personality has influenced changes to the storyline and they continually surprise me with what they say. I can’t tell you how often I go back and re-read portions of the series and I wonder ‘who wrote this?’ I love the writing process, but I truly believe the story writes itself, I’m only a tool to put it on paper.

    • Tina,
      Thanks for your comment. I’ve had similar experiences in which characters have taken over my stories. Sometimes you have to just let that happen. Other times, you need to reclaim your story. Thanks for stopping by.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s